How Council was advised on Three Waters

“It’s all the non-financial stuff that should drive the reason for change…”

Dan Bonifant, the managing director of Morrison Low Consultants, agrees that the WICS Scottish model for household water rates (which was used to base the Three waters system on) is not a reliable one to apply to New Zealand: “It’s 30-year modelling, so there’s inherent uncertainty.” Other analysts have also stated that the figures are not reliable and that the Three Waters plan is trying to apply Scotland’s situation to New Zealand when we are completely different.

His advice to Council on August 31, is to look at the wide range of potential benefits, risks and challenges, not just the finances; things such as:

  • the role of iwi;
  • our Council’s role (or lack of) within the new ‘Entity C’;
  • ensuring that we Nelsonians get the level of service that we need..

“My advice is, don’t just make it based on the financial information — there’s so much more to it than this. It’s all the non-financial stuff that should drive the reason for change.”



More Posts

Here’s what you told Council…

** Click on each image to enlarge it. How would you prefer to vote? For example, only councillors in your ward and the mayor, or…? Do you feel connected to


We’re concerned that some organisations are spreading inflammatory and incorrect ‘information’ (read emotional hype) about Three Waters. LET’S BE CLEAR: Nelson councillors were NOT voting YES or NO  on whether

What the heck IS this Three Waters anyway?

What the heck IS this 3-waters thing? From the horse’s mouth: (we’ve added the headings) ” In July 2020, the Government launched the Three Waters Reform Programme – a three-year programme to

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x